Alabama football, Joel Klatt.
Credit: Steve Roberts-Imagn Images, The Joel Klatt Show

We got another look at the College Football Playoff selection committee’s rankings on Tuesday, and there is once again plenty to talk about.

While there were a few eyebrow-raising decisions across the top 25 — four ranked four-loss SEC teams, Arizona moving up four spots with a loss, Indiana at No. 8 after its shuffling last week — the biggest question mark by a pretty wide margin was the committee’s ranking of No. 3 Alabama relative to No. 5 Texas.

There was no great move here, as Alabama held serve at No. 3 with a comfortable win over Vanderbilt, while Texas moved up one spot following its on-the-road win over No. 21 LSU. Instead, it was the lack of movement that was the real news. After the Hoosiers got punished during their bye week, presumably as a result of several of their previous wins taking losses while they were off, many expected the same to happen for the Crimson Tide this week, as Alabama’s five best wins this season all lost this past week. Instead, the committee remained unshaken in its faith in Bama.

Joel Klatt, who has never been shy about sharing his opinions on the committee’s rankings, did not hold back while breaking down what he saw as an insult to college football fans.

“I feel like we’re in an Orwell novel right now,” Klatt said on Wednesday. “The committee is basically insisting we reject the evidence right before our eyes. Right in front of our faces. It is like their most essential command.

“I see the resume between Alabama and Texas. Two spots behind Alabama is Texas, and Texas’ resume is so much better than Alabama’s. Their best wins, Bama, are now Kentucky and South Carolina, who just got the hinges blown off of their front door by Arkansas. … Texas beat Tennessee and Ohio State. A Tennessee team that beat Alabama. There’s no comparing those two resumes. You took a wrong turn, you’re telling us it’s a shortcut, and now you’re just stubborn. Take the crayons away from the committee.”

Klatt then imagined a conversation he’d have with a defender of the committee’s current ranking, pointing out the circular reasoning of those that argue in favor of the SEC’s ranked four-loss teams.

“The Tide looked very average. ‘Yeah, but hey, it was in the SEC.’ Well, why is that good? ‘Well, because nine teams are ranked.’ Yeah, but why were nine teams ranked? ‘Well, because the SEC is really good.’ Why is the SEC really good? ‘Well, because nine teams are ranked.’ Oh! See I didn’t get it the first time. Thank you for clarifying.

“None of it makes sense. They’re asking us to suspend all of our faculties and just believe what they give us, and I refuse to do that.”

Take the crayons away from the committee. https://t.co/0sBVAfEvtx

— The Joel Klatt Show: A College Football on FOX Pod (@JoelKlattShow) November 18, 2026

The weekly ceremony of the rankings show is starting to get pretty exhausting, as the committee’s logic can sometimes fail to add up in a way that makes sense from week to week. But while the show may be frustrating, it at least provides a starting point for some very good, very angry content from across the rest of the college football media landscape.

The post Joel Klatt blasts CFP’s Orwellian ranking of Alabama over Texas appeared first on Awful Announcing.

Source: Yahoo Sports