P.J. Fleck should be facing immense pressure to get the Gophers’ offensive coordinator hire right. He has built up enough goodwill to get an opportunity to do so, but another wrong move could quickly make his long-term seat atop the Minnesota program red-hot.
Minnesota has had just three offenses rank in the top half of FBS football in points per game in Fleck’s 10 seasons with the program. All three of those units were coordinated by Kirk Ciarrocca, who’s currently the offensive play-caller at Rutgers. His future with the Scarlet Knights is up in the air, but Fleck cannot bring him back again if he becomes available. Theoretically, he’d probably be an upgrade over what Minnesota has had, but the Gophers need to think bigger.
It’s no secret that Minnesota ranks near the bottom of the Big Ten in financial resources to build its coaching staff and roster. In 2024, its assistant coaching salary pool was dead last in the conference, and Fleck ranks near the middle in terms of head coaching salary. Why that’s the case is a much broader discussion, but some of the responsibility falls on the head coach and his relationship with the administration. Annual raises and contract extensions become a lot harder to defend when you can’t afford a good offensive coordinator.
Hiring a new offensive coordinator isn’t just a big decision for Fleck; it’s a big decision for the University of Minnesota and how seriously it wants to take football. It’s obvious that Fleck does a lot of things well, but it’s also obvious that he has clear weaknesses as a head coach, and his archaic offensive philosophy is near the top of the list.
“Everybody thinks offensive football and goes right to the points, or the yards. That’s not necessarily what I am looking at. Are we able to sustain a drive long enough to punt and pin somebody down inside their own five, and play really good defense, and play the 78% rule? We’re really good at that… A punt isn’t a bad play in football,” Fleck said at his weekly press conference on Monday.
“Of course you want to score every time you have the ball. I want to make sure I am really clear: ‘The coach doesn’t want to score points?’ That’s not true. ‘He doesn’t want to have a lot of yards.’ That’s not true. But you can have a lot of yards and not score any points… Can we do what we need to do philosophically, and do what it takes to win here within our culture and program?”
Programs like UCLA and Indiana were considered dead-end jobs before hiring Bob Chesney and Curt Cignetti, respectively. Fleck was once considered that type of coach, one with innovative ideas who wanted to push the boundaries. Now, he has morphed into a Kirk Ferentz wannabe.
It’s one thing if Minnesota were winning even eight games every regular season, but it hasn’t done that since 2022, and a streak of four straight years at 7-5 or worse will continue this fall. What exactly are you “really good” at? Minnesota hasn’t even been ranked in a major poll since the 2022 season.
Ignoring the possibility that his philosophy could use some improvement is a huge red flag surrounding Fleck right now. You should only take so much from a press conference, but he continues to avoid admitting that he’s wrong.
If Fleck opts to promote from within, current wide receivers coach Isaac Fruechte is a fine choice, but will he bring new ideas to the table? Or will Fleck continue to think punting is a good play? If Minnesota doesn’t hire from outside the program, we could be looking at the slow death of Fleck’s time with the Gophers.
We don’t need to break down his resume, but Fleck has earned more than enough goodwill to get a shot at the 24-team playoff for at least one season in 2027. If he promotes Fruechte or another in-house option, how do we know anything will change next season? Are we just delaying the inevitable? He sounds like a head coach who’s comfortable with having an archaic offense and relying on above-average defense and improved special teams to win games.
The last time Fleck hired an offensive or defensive coordinator from outside the program, Corey Hetherman quickly turned Minnesota’s defense into one of the best units in the Big Ten before leaving for Miami (FL) after one season. Fleck needs to learn from that decision and take another big swing this offseason because his back is against the wall.
Source: Yahoo Sports









Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account