
Four weeks ago, I wrote that it might be time to overreact to Duke’s exhibition dominance. A 40 point dismantling of a Top 10 team, even in an exhibition, was justified cause for unbridled excitement. More than the statistical dominance, though, it was how the Blue Devils looked in the exhibition season—not just in annihilating Tennessee at home, but later in a win in Allen Fieldhouse against the likely No. 1 pick in next year’s NBA draft—that had Duke fans salivating for the regular season.
Against strong exhibition competition, the Blue Devils looked fluid offensively. They were connected and suffocating defensively. John Blackwell looked the part of the most coveted guard in the transfer portal, Joaquim Boumtje Boumtje oozed potential, and returnees Pat Ngongba II, Dame Sarr, and Cayden Boozer all appeared to have improved significantly over the offseason.
None of that was on display Tuesday night in Cameron Indoor Stadium.
Duke’s performance was worse than the final score indicated—and a 21 point home loss to a short-handed opponent is already cause for alarm. The Blue Devils were disjointed and sloppy offensively. They were outworked on the glass. They were humiliated defensively by Andrej Stojakovic’s all-time performance. These facts are sufficient to justify panic, even more so given similar issues were on display in last week’s lethargic loss to Michigan State (even if they weren’t as apparent in the final boxscore).
It might, then, be time to overreact once again: we must now reckon with the possibility that this Duke team was massively overrated. Maybe Blackwell isn’t the plug-and-play scorer the Blue Devils thought they were getting from the portal and too much was expected from a 17-year-old Boumtje Boumtje. Perhaps the steps forward we saw early from Ngongba, Sarr, and Boozer were mirages. Most concerningly, this mix of returnees, particularly raw freshmen, and coveted transfers just might not fit together.
Make no mistake, this is a five-alarm fire for this team. Jon Scheyer all but admitted as much in his postgame media availability and said there will be major changes to come. Duke can certainly no longer be considered a national title favorite, as was widelypredicted by the college basketball media.
But this is also a new age in college basketball, one where there are real-world observations driving those pre-season predictions. Duke’s dominant exhibition performances still happened. There is proof of principle that this Blue Devil can be a team that beats a Top 10 opponent by 40 points and convincingly wins in one of the most challenging road venues in the sport. The very same players that failed to compete in Cameron last night were on the floor in those exhibition contests.
To be clear, Duke cannot beat Top-10 teams with Blackwell scoring in the single digits on sub 30% shooting from deep; but, we have seen the hyper-efficient scorer and deadeye shooter fans expected in a Duke uniform against in the exhibitions against Tennessee and Kansas. Duke cannot compete for a National Championship with Ngongba playing like a stretch-5 and having more fouls than rebounds; but, we have seen the version of Ngongba that is a dominant paint presence when he put up 28 points and 10 rebounds in the exhibition versus the Jayhawks. Duke will not return to the Final Four if Boozer can’t impact the game with his passing, if Sarr’s offensive game hasn’t truly evolved, and if this becomes a true apprenticeship year for Boumtje Boumtje; but, we have seen Boozer tally double-digit assists, Sarr confidently attack the basket, and truly special plays from Boumtje Boumtje all within the past month.
It must also be recognized that a turnaround from such a dispiriting start is far from unprecedented—just last season, Florida lost four of its first nine games, including four of its seven contests against power-conference opponents, before earning a No. 1 seed in the NCAA Tournament with a dominant SEC run. That Gator team, it should be noted, shares some notable similarities with this Blue Devil team: both teams were expecting major, but complementary, players from the previous season to step up into new roles along with new pieces intended to fill gaps left by outgoing stars.
This Duke team could very well follow a similar path to that Florida squad. That will require Scheyer to determine what caused the change between the Blue Devils we saw in October and November and for his players to do some soul searching. Hopefully that leads to this Duke team’s true identity, which lies somewhere between the hyperbolic overreaction to its exhibition success and the despair of last night’s humiliation.
Lesson learned: it is, in fact, never time to overreact.
Go to the DBR Boards to find Blue Healer Auctions || Drop us a line
Source: Yahoo Sports









Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account