NORMAN, Okla. — John Mateer played his last game at Gaylord Family — Oklahoma Memorial Stadium on Saturday as the Sooners’ starting quarterback. He has at least two more games left in his college career: a road trip to Columbia next week to face the Missouri Tigers, then the Sooners’ bowl game to end the year. But for now, his time at the Palace on the Prairie has ended.
When assessing the legacy of a starting quarterback at a place like Oklahoma, the standard is extremely high. Oklahoma has been known as QBU for years, home to several Heisman winners, including Jason White, Sam Bradford, Baker Mayfield, and Kyler Murray. Then there are the current NFL quarterbacks who have played for the Sooners, such as Mayfield, Murray, Jalen Hurts, Spencer Rattler, Caleb Williams, and Dillon Gabriel.
That’s a lot of pressure for a two-year quarterback. Mateer didn’t shy away from it, but he did not live up to the standard either. His time as the Sooners’ starting quarterback is hard to sum up in a neat little package.
The Hype, the Thumb Injury, and the 2025 Rollercoaster
In the winter of 2025, Mateer transferred from Washington State to follow offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle to Oklahoma. The hype around them was huge. They were expected to bring the Oklahoma offense back to its past standards. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case.
His junior campaign started with plenty of excitement. Mateer was the Heisman favorite, with a breakout performance against Michigan and leading a comeback win over Auburn. But as the season went on, the offense grew more inconsistent, with Mateer front and center.
At the end of his first month as the Sooners’ signal-caller, Mateer suffered a thumb injury. What no one knew at the time was that after the injury, he would never be the same player.
He returned against Texas and threw three interceptions. It was clear he had not returned to his early-season form. But even with the bad play, Mateer led the Sooners to 10 wins, an undefeated November with road wins at Alabama and Tennessee, and a trip to the College Football Playoff.
2026 Struggles, a Cotton Bowl Spark, and the Witten Reset
As Mateer began his senior season, he was finally healthy with his thumb fully healed. Many people expected Mateer to return to his early 2025 form in 2026. After a strong start against UTEP in a glorified scrimmage, Mateer’s play declined in the games that followed, looking even worse than how he looked in the second half of the previous year.
His performances against Michigan, New Mexico, and Georgia left a sour taste in Sooner fans' mouths, with many wondering if his days as Oklahoma's starting quarterback were numbered.
The biggest game of the season was the Red River Shootout against No. 1 Texas in Dallas. Mateer had very little room for error. However, he led the Sooners to a massive comeback win over the Longhorns. It was a huge victory for the program and brought a lot of relief.
But after that big win, the same old Mateer returned with shaky performances against Kentucky, Mississippi State, and South Carolina. This ultimately led to the dismissal of Arbuckle as Oklahoma’s offensive coordinator, the same guy who brought Mateer to Norman.
Then came Jason Witten, as head coach Brent Venables named Witten as Arbuckle’s replacement in an interim role. Witten’s first objective was to fix Mateer, and sure enough, it worked.
The last three games have been a huge improvement for Mateer and the Sooners’ offense. He has helped lead Oklahoma to wins against Florida, Ole Miss, and Texas A&M on Saturday in Norman.
The biggest difference was that Witten played to Mateer’s strengths instead of trying to get the quarterback to play hero ball on every snap. Witten has also done a better job establishing the ground game and controlling the clock, which has made Mateer much more effective.
How You Remember a Run Like That
In his two years as the Sooners’ starting quarterback, Mateer hasn’t had any earth-shattering numbers. Mateer has been a steady dual-threat production as Oklahoma's starting quarterback, combining for more than 5,700 total yards and 38 total touchdowns.
History will not remember Mateer as one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever suit up for the crimson and cream. Nor should he be thought of as one of the worst either. Instead, he occupies the gray area of real college football. The high points of his time in Norman have been incredibly exciting, and the low points have tested Oklahoma fans' patience on numerous occasions.
While Mateer was not a superstar and showed several obvious flaws on more than one occasion, he did display a lot of grit during his tenure. He never quit, he never stopped competing, and he gave Sooner fans memories they'll hold onto from Michigan and Auburn to Alabama, Tennessee, a CFP berth, and beating Texas.
Along the way, he helped the team weather a storm and gave Oklahoma a real look at what Witten can do calling plays.
Nobody needs to mourn that this chapter is wrapping up—a fresh start makes sense for all sides. Still, you’re fooling yourself if you can't smile about the good moments that came along for the ride.
Source: Yahoo Sports








Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account