If you had told any Norman or Austin barbershop in August that Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer would be ranked higher than the golden boy from Texas, Arch Manning, in mid-November, you would have been laughed out of the shop.
The Texas quarterback was touted as the Heisman frontrunner, the No. 1 overall pick in the NFL Draft, and the centerpiece of the most expensive offense in college football under the “offensive genius” of head coach Steve Sarkisian. Meanwhile, Mateer struggled with an offensive line thrown together at the last minute, a revolving door of injured skill players, and an offense so stagnant it got offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle fired.
Fast forward to mid-November and the narrative has flipped. ESPN’s updated Power 4 quarterback rankings, which evaluate all 68 starting quarterbacks in the Power 4 conferences, rank John Mateer as the No. 34 quarterback in the country, one spot ahead of Arch Manning at No. 35.
When you take away the recruiting stars, last names, and the outrageous amounts of money that Manning is being paid, Connelly has a point.
What Happened at the Cotton Bowl
Before we look at the numbers for November, let’s go back to October 10 and the Red River Shootout, where these two quarterbacks faced each other. Oklahoma won an epic upset over No. 1 Texas in Dallas, 27-24.
Texas got off to a great start, and as the game progressed, Manning showed flashes of his great potential. He completed 19 of 31 for 260 yards and three touchdowns, while adding 20 yards on the ground for a touchdown as Texas went into the half up 17-7. The fourth quarter was a different story as Venables and the Sooners' defense brought the heat. Manning threw a pick-six to Cam Coleman as Peyton Bowen jumped the pass and returned it 42 yards for a touchdown. After Manning threw a game-tying touchdown to Jermaine Bishop Jr. with 1:19 left, he threw a second interception to Courtland Guillory with 19 seconds to go in the game. That gave Oklahoma the ball at the 31-yard line, and Mateer led the Sooners to victory in four plays.
Mateer went 18-of-26 through the air for 155 yards, with three sacks and negative-six rushing yards. However, after throwing three interceptions in the 2025 version of the Red River Rivalry, Mateer played smart, disciplined football and protected the rock on several occasions as his defense and special teams dominated the game. With less than 20 seconds remaining, Mateer led the Sooners on a four-play, 31-yard game-winning drive highlighted by a 13-yard completion to Isaiah Sategna III and a 20-yard pass to the same receiver. Tate Sandell then booted a 47-yard walk-off field goal for the Sooners. One quarterback gave the game away; the other went out and won it.
The Jason Witten Effect
As Connelly noted in his breakdown, Mateer’s surge over the past month didn't happen in a vacuum. "We've seen a spark from Mateer over the past month," Connelly wrote. "It didn't come quickly enough to save offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle's job (or OU's season), but in his past four games, he has produced a 73.6 Total QBR, zero interceptions, higher quality rushing and three wins. And after averaging 15.8 points in the first four games against power-conference opponents, the Sooners have averaged 23.8 in the past four. Great? No way. Decent? Absolutely."
Since Brent Venables handed the play-calling duties to interim offensive coordinator Jason Witten, Mateer has looked like a completely liberated football player. Witten simplified the passing game into quick one- and two-read progressions, stopped asking Mateer to play hero ball on every dropback, and unleashed his legs.
The results speak for themselves. Mateer is currently the only quarterback in the entire country to start his team's last four games without committing a single turnover. Over the last two weeks alone—leading Oklahoma to physical, ranked wins over No. 24 Florida (23-7) and No. 19 Ole Miss (24-17)—Mateer has carried the ball 30 times for 126 yards, accounting for nearly half of his 271 rushing yards on the season. He carved up Florida for 207 passing yards, two touchdowns, and 56 rushing yards, then followed that up in the pouring rain against Ole Miss with a season-high 70 rushing yards, his first rushing score of the year, and 111 yards through the air. Through 10 games for the 6-4 Sooners, he has completed 64.5% of his passes (193 of 299) for 2,153 yards, 15 touchdowns, and seven interceptions.
Manning’s Roller Coaster in Austin
Meanwhile, down in Austin, Manning’s season has been a weekly stress test for Longhorn fans. Yes, Texas is 8-2 and sitting at No. 5 in the CFP race, and yes, Manning has pulled off some fourth-quarter magic to spark a four-game winning streak—including last Saturday's 22-21 comeback win at LSU, where he shook off three interceptions and four sacks to run for 35 yards and a score before throwing a four-yard game-winning touchdown to Raleek Brown with seconds left.
Across that four-game streak, Manning has totaled 46 rushing yards and all three of his rushing touchdowns on 39 carries (dragged down by 13 sacks), bringing his season totals to 2,198 passing yards, 19 touchdowns, 10 interceptions, and 154 rushing yards.
| Stat Category (2026 Season) | John Mateer (Oklahoma) | Arch Manning (Texas) |
| Passer Rating | 136.9 | 143.2 |
| Passing Yards / TDs / INTs | 2,153 yds / 15 TDs / 7 INTs | 2,198 yds / 19 TDs / 10 INTs |
| Net Rushing Yards / TDs | 271 yds (116 car.) / 1 TD | 154 yds (88 car.) / 3 TDs |
| Total Offense / Total TDs | 2,424 yds / 16 TDs | 2,352 yds / 22 TDs |
The Verdict: Disappointment vs. Grit
Look at the side-by-side numbers, and it’s dead even. Manning holds a slight edge in passer rating (143.2 to 136.9) and total touchdowns (22 to 16), while Mateer leads in total yards (2,424 to 2,352), ground volume (28 more carries and 117 more rushing yards), and ball security.
So can we sit here and pound the table saying Mateer is definitively a more talented quarterback than Manning? No. But the far more honest assessment is that Arch Manning is easily the bigger disappointment.
Manning isn't in the Heisman conversation; he looks nowhere near a first-round NFL Draft pick right now, and he’s burning through a massive NIL budget just to throw 10 picks in an offense loaded with five-star weapons. In fact, barring a miracle finish, it wouldn't shock anyone if Sarkisian and Manning head toward a quiet divorce this offseason—with Manning hitting the transfer portal for another school, potentially even inside the SEC, rather than heading to the NFL.
Mateer, on the other hand, has taken every punch this season has thrown at him—a bad offensive line, injured receivers, a midseason coordinator firing—and come out swinging under Jason Witten. When you factor in the price tag, the surrounding circumstances, and who walked out of Dallas with the Golden Hat, ESPN got it right. Right now, you take Mateer.
Source: Yahoo Sports








Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account