Wisconsin Badgers Coaching Candidates, Luke Fickell, Badgers Coaching Search, Wisconsin Coaching Candidates
IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Wisconsin Badgers head coach Luke Fickell entered the 2026 college football season on the hot seat after posting a combined 16-21 record across his first three seasons with the program. A 4-1 start entering early October seemed to be a turning point for the program, but its collapse down the stretch has made a Badgers coaching search feel mandatory.

Fortunately for Wisconsin, it could enter the college football coaching carousel at a time when it would have one of the best jobs available. Many programs with coaches in tenuous situations might wait until after College Football Playoff expansion in 2027 to make a move, creating an opportunity for the University of Wisconsin to strike while the iron is hot.

Let’s jump into our list of Badgers coaching candidates to replace Fickell.

Jake Dickert, Wake Forest Demon Deacons Head Coach

Wisconsin Badgers Coaching Candidates, Jake Dickert
Nov 14, 2026; Dallas, Texas, USA; Wake Forest Demon Deacons head coach Jake Dickert celebrates with his team during the first half against the SMU Mustangs at Gerald J. Ford Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images

Wake Forest Demon Deacons head coach Jake Dickert might not be a Wisconsin-Madison alum, but he should arguably be the first name called if there’s a Badgers coaching search. Dickert, 43, grew up in Wisconsin, where he played high school football at Oconto High School and later Kohler. He stayed close to home for college, playing for Wisconsin-Stevens Point, and he stayed there as a graduate assistant in 2007. After working his way up the coaching ladder, with stints throughout the Dakotas and Minnesota, he finally landed his first Power 4 job with Washington State in 2020.

Dickert earned his first shot at being a head coach just a year later, taking over as the Cougars’ interim head coach after Nick Rolovich and many of his top assistants were fired midseason. In the interim role, Dickert posted a 3-3 record and won three of his last four games in the regular season. Washington State removed the interim tag, and he delivered a 20-17 record. The success put him on Wake Forest’s radar, where he’s delivered consecutive nine-win seasons after the program had eight combined wins from 2023-24 under Dave Clawson. Dickert’s defense has been excellent this year, ranking 11th in scoring (15 PPG allowed), and he could bring over offensive coordinator Rob Ezell with him to Madison.

Jason Eck, New Mexico Lobos Head Coach

Wisconsin Badgers Coaching Candidates, Jason Eck
Oct 17, 2026; Honolulu, Hawaii, USA; New Mexico Lobos head coach Jason Eck walks off the field before his team takes on the Hawaii Rainbow Warriors at the Clarence T.C. Ching Athletics Complex. Mandatory Credit: Marco Garcia-Imagn Images

Jason Eck is going to be atop just about every Wisconsin coaching candidates list. After all, the current New Mexico Lobos head coach played on the Badgers offensive line (1995-98) and then worked on Barry Alvarez’s staff as a graduate assistant from 1999-2001. A native of La Crosse, Wisconsin, Eck then worked around the country as an offensive line coach, eventually becoming an offensive coordinator at Minnesota State (2013-14) and South Dakota State (2019-21). As with Dickert, Eck is now in his second head-coaching stint with a track record of winning at both stops.

Eck took over the Idaho Vandals football program after the team went a combined 6-11 in the two seasons prior to his arrival. Instantly, he delivered seven wins in his first year at the helm, with Idaho making the FCS playoffs for the first time since 2016. The Vandals went 19-8 over the next two seasons, reaching the FCS quarterfinals each time and falling off immediately (4-8 in 2025) after his departure. As the Lobos head coach, Eck has won eight-plus games in each of his first two seasons at a school that had never done that dating back to the 1930s. Most impressive, Eck’s offense has been successful this season despite losing starting quarterback Jack Layne to season-ending surgery in August. If Eck can win nine-plus games in consecutive years with two different starting quarterbacks at New Mexico, imagine what he could accomplish at his alma mater with the Badgers’ resources.

Related: Early College Football Coaching Carousel Predictions, including Wisconsin Badgers

Jim Leonhard, Buffalo Bills Defensive Coordinator

Wisconsin Badgers Coaching Candidates, Jim Leonhard
Dec 27, 2022; Phoenix, Arizona, USA; Wisconsin Badgers defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard with his son following the game against the Oklahoma State Cowboys during the 2022 Guaranteed Rate Bowl at Chase Field. Mandatory Credit: Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

Would Jim Leonhard consider returning to his alma mater after previously being passed over for Luke Fickell? Still just 44 years old, Leonhard was a two-time All-American and the heart of the Badgers defense for years. Two years after his playing career in the NFL ended, he joined the Badgers coaching staff under Paul Chryst and worked his way up from defensive backs coach (2016) to interim head coach after Chryst was fired midway through the 2022 season. Wisconsin went 4-3 during his interim stint, with losses to Michigan State and Minnesota decided by one score. However, the school chose Fickell over the fan favorite, with The Athletic reporting at the time that it came down to head-coaching experience. In hindsight, Leonhard’s familiarity with the program and his unique understanding of what was required to be consistently great should’ve been the priority.

A Badgers coaching search this offseason could mean an opportunity to correct that mistake years later. Leonhard has spent the last three seasons in the NFL, learning from the likes of Sean Payton and Vance Joseph before landing the Buffalo Bills defensive coordinator position this past offseason. Still well-regarded for his defensive mind, with a proven track record of success as a play-caller in college, Leonhard would be an attractive option to bring home.

Tim Polasek, North Dakota State Bison Head Coach

Wisconsin Badgers Coaching Candidates, Tim Polasek
Nov 14, 2026; Honolulu, Hawaii, USA; NDSU Bison head coach Tim Polasek is seen on the field before his team takes on Hawaii Rainbow Warriors at Clarence T.C. Ching Athletics Complex. Mandatory Credit: Marco Garcia-Imagn Images

If Wisconsin is conducting a coaching search this winter, it is difficult to imagine a scenario where either Jason Eck or Jake Dickert does not take over the football program. We do have to consider, however, that Luke Fickell has a $21.3 million buyout and that is not including the costs of replacing the Badgers coaching staff then bringing in a new one. Money can be an issue and if that were to be the case, we will highlight Tim Polasek. The North Dakota State head coach led his team to the Division I FCS title last year behind a 14-2 record, and the program followed that up with a 12-1 record last season. Making the jump to the Mountain West Conference in 2026, Polasek’s Bison have gone 8-2 and nearly beat Eck’s Lobos in New Mexico (21-16). The 47-year-old is also a Wisconsin native, with those ties to the region making him an under-the-radar name to keep in mind if Fickell gets fired and money is tight for the Badgers athletic department.

Source: Yahoo Sports