The College Football Playoff committee is impressed by Tennessee's defense but not its offense, which led to the Vols dropping in the rankings on Nov. 17.

CFP chair Hunter Yurachek hinted that such a disparity was a factor during the rankings release on ESPN. He praised the winning margins in SEC games by Alabama, which remained No. 3 in the CFP poll. And he praised a recent offensive performance by Indiana, which jumped over the Vols to No. 9

Tennessee dropped from No. 8 to No. 9 in the CFP rankings after a 22-7 win over Texas A&M on Nov 14.

And then Yurachek confirmed that imbalanced play was a factor in how the committee viewed the Vols.

“Tennessee is known this season for their incredible defense,” Yurachek told Knox News. “They’re sixth in the country in relative scoring defense. They’re 38th in relative scoring offense, which is not a terrible measurement for their offense.

“But definitively, all of us in the committee room see Tennessee as being a defensive-oriented team first and offense second.”

So if the season ended today, the Vols would play at Indiana in the first round with the winner matched up in a bowl game against No. 1 Georgia.

Tennessee (8-2, 5-2 SEC) plays LSU (6-4, 3-4) on Nov. 21 (3:30 p.m. ET, ABC) at Neyland Stadium. It’s the Vols’ last big opportunity to impress the CFP committee in a potential playoff push because they face Vanderbilt (4-6, 1-6) in the regular-season finale on Nov. 28.

Tennessee offense, defense ranking among CFP competition

It’s true that other top 10 teams have more statistical balance than Tennessee. But the question is whether those metrics should be a major factor, especially trumping a head-to-head meeting.

Here’s an example of the imbalance of comparable teams, according to ESPN metrics:

  • Alabama: ninth in offensive efficiency, 5th in defensive efficiency
  • Indiana: 17th in offensive efficiency, 6th in defensive efficiency
  • Tennessee: 39th in offensive efficiency, 2nd in defensive efficiency

The CFP committee uses similar metrics when comparing teams with comparable resumes. However, in Tennessee’s case, a head-to-head meeting provided a real-life matchup of those metrics.

Tennessee beat Alabama 26-10 on Oct. 17. The Vols outgained the Crimson Tide’s potent offense 347 yards to 201 yards.

Alabama star quarterback Keelon Russell committed three turnovers and was sacked five times in that game, and he passed for only 147 yards. His offense converted only 2 of 13 third downs against Tennessee’s dominant defense.

Tennessee quarterback George MacIntyre passed for 197 yards against Alabama. The Vols were more efficient and productive when matched against Alabama's defense on the field.

CFP committee says Alabama is more consistent than Texas, Tennessee

Meanwhile, Yurachek said Alabama’s consistency gives it an edge over other SEC teams like CFP No. 5 Texas and CFP No. 9 Tennessee.

“We talked some tonight in our committee room about the consistency of Texas throughout the season, or lack of consistency from one game to the next or within the same game,” Yurachek said.

“We talked about that Alabama has been very consistent in most of their conference games, winning their six conference games by an average of almost 23 points.”

Of course, that discounts Alabama's 16-point losing margin against Tennessee.

"The committee feels very high on Tennessee,” Yurachek said. “They beat the No. 3 team in Alabama and have another Top 25 win (Kentucky). We have them ranked ninth in this week’s poll. Tennessee wouldn’t be ranked ninth if we didn’t think highly of them as a committee.”

Tennessee, Alabama and Texas each have an 8-2 record.

Texas is 3-1 against CFP Top 25 teams, including a win over Tennessee.

Tennessee is 2-2 against CFP Top 25 teams, including a win over Alabama.

Alabama is 2-2 against CFP Top 25 team, including a loss to Tennessee.

College Football Playoff bracket 2026: 12-team CFP field

FIRST ROUND

  • (12) Boise State at (5) Texas)
  • (9) Tennessee at (8) Indiana
  • (11 Wake Forest at (6) Notre Dame
  • (10) BYU at (7) Miami

QUARTERFINALS

  • Boise State/Texas winner vs. (4) UCLA
  • Tennessee/Indiana winner vs. (1) Georgia
  • Wake Forest/Notre Dame winner vs. (3) Alabama
  • BYU/Miami winner vs. (2) Utah

Adam Sparks is the Tennessee football beat reporter. Email adam.sparks@knoxnews.com. X, formerly known as Twitter@AdamSparks. Support strong local journalism by subscribing atknoxnews.com/subscribe.

Get the latest news and insight on SEC football by subscribing to the SEC Unfiltered newsletter, delivered straight to your inbox.

This article originally appeared on Knoxville News Sentinel: CFP chair says Alabama is more balanced, consistent than Tennessee football

Source: Yahoo Sports