
The 2026 Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award finalists were announced on Friday, with many of the nation’s top quarterbacks in the mix for the honor. However, there was one major surprise for college football fans with the Miami Hurricanes‘ Darian Mensah kept off in favor of the Texas Longhorns‘ Arch Manning.
No one could argue against the inclusions of CJ Carr (Notre Dame Fighting Irish), Devon Dampier (Utah Utes) and Drew Mestemaker (Oklahoma State Cowboys). All three quarterbacks had resumes and numbers worthy of being recognized as the nation’s best upperclassman quarterback in college football. However, the difference in stats between Mensah and Manning are staggering.
Read More: Best College Football Defenses Right Now
Mensah has statistically been the best quarterback in college football this season, averaging the most passing yards per game (307.6) among the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award finalists while ranking fourth nationally in passing touchdown rate, third in yards per attempt (9.7) and first in ESPN QBR (88.6). Both statistically and based on record (9-1 vs. 9-2), he should be ahead of Manning.
At a time when there’s a growing belief among fans and even college football analysts that the College Football Playoff rankings are heavily biased toward SEC teams, this seemed like another example of conference favoritism. So, why isn’t Mensah a Golden Arm finalist?
Because under the criteria set forth by the Golden Arm Foundation, a quarterback is ineligible from consideration if they’ve transferred twice. Mensah started for the Tulane Green Wave in 2024 before transferring to become a star with the Duke Blue Devils this past season. By transferring a second time to replace Carson Beck as the Hurricanes’ quarterback in 2026, he made himself ineligible for the Johnny Unitas Golden Arm Award.
It certainly feels like an outdated criterion given the state of modern college football, but it could also be a non-issue in the years to come if the NCAA and Power Four conferences have their way with changes to transfer rules. For now, Mensah is ineligible, and Manning inexplicably made the list despite being an average starting quarterback this season.
Source: Yahoo Sports









Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account