
As the Michigan Wolverines trotted off the field following a 31-7 loss to the Oregon Ducks, it was hard to consider how things could get much worse. New offensive play caller Jim Harding told the Michigan pregame radio that he shared with the staff that he “needs help.” Meanwhile, his message to the players was that they needed to “breathe life into the plays.”
The result? Quarterbacks that went 6-for-20 as they bounced in and out of game and 286 total yards of offense, two turnovers, and seven measly points. But it wasn’t just on the offensive end; Oregon jumped to a 14-point lead and never looked back. Against a team the Wolverines should annually compete with for the Big Ten crown, they were manhandled from start to finish in the latest example that this team has nothing left.
What we learned: Michigan has squandered two young QBs
The mismanagement of the quarterback room by this coaching staff has been dumbfounding. For a head coach like Kyle Whittingham to have decades of experience in this game, he has to understand the cultural dynamics of a quarterback change. As Michigan went from Bryce Underwood to Tommy Carr, there was newfound hope, despite growing pains that were expected from a true freshman quarterback.
What that meant was a world of pressure on Carr, the legacy name that was taking over for a five-star making millions. Instead of his head coaching continuing to give him votes of confidence, here’s how Whittingham handled the new quarterback battle following the comeback since the loss to Minnesota:
- After Minnesota loss: “Jason [Beck] will call plays, and Bryce is our guy, and we move forward.”
- After Penn State win: Whittingham said, “I’m not gonna say I was against (the move from Underwood to Carr) but they said, ‘Hey, thinking about making changes’… I’m not sitting here making a decision going forward who it’s gonna be because it was not just Bryce Underwood in the first half that wasn’t playing at the top of their game.”
- Heading into the Indiana game:“We know exactly what we’re doing… The plan going forward, we’re not going to tip our hand to to the opponent, but we have a good plan in place, and that’s about all I can say on that right now.”
- After loss to Indiana: Whittingham was asked point-blank who the starter was. His answer: “That’s to be determined. We don’t want to play this game every week, who’s going to start. But it’s a decision that we’ll make in the next couple days, keep it to ourselves until somebody lets the cat out of the bag, and go from there.”
- Following the Rutgers win: “Liked everything about what (Carr) did,” said Whittingham, saying Carr will start for “the foreseeable future.”
- Finally after the loss to Michigan State: Whittingham immediately gives up on Carr, saying the starting role is “to be determined” and that they thought about reinserting Underwood against the Spartans to “try and create something.” While saying they’d, “take a look at everything again and see what gives us the best chance to win.”
In Saturday’s loss to Oregon, Carr started, but Underwood played the second quarter. Then, Carr came back out to start the second half until Underwood returned at the end of the game. In the four games Carr has started, he got ONE vote of confidence from his head coach in the media, where he made it sound like his position was solid. As soon as he started to struggle against Michigan State, the first real adversity he faced behind a broken offensive line and an abysmal play caller, they were ALREADY having conversations about going back to Underwood? The foreseeable future Whittingham mentioned after Rutgers lasted five quarters. It’s indefensible.
Culturally, who is the leader of this offense? When it’s not the coaches, that’s what confidence in a quarterback affords even in the worst of moments. Teammates play hard for the guy who takes the most weight on offense. That’s typically the signal caller, and it’s why it is the most important position in sports. There was energy and momentum on this team when Carr took over. You could see it on the field as he made plays, but players in the locker room were raving each week about his work ethic and will to win. But, in the first game since firing Beck, this coaching staff decided to pull the plug on Carr after one quarter.
I’m not saying Carr was playing well. But these are the punches you role with when you make the decision to go to a freshman. Let him earn his scars, gain experience, and be ready to compete for a job the following season with a locker room that is hopefully behind him.
Instead, the coaches threw Carr into the deep end. This is a young man the coaches said had the “it factor” and was a “natural born leader” before the season. They looked at a resume that constituted of less than a month’s worth of football that was filled with drama on and off the field and still decided to go back to Underwood. Think of the message that sends to these two student athletes, the fans and the locker room — there’s absolutely nothing to build on here.
The handling of this situation is a microcosm of the complete ineptitude and lack of care this coaching staff continues to display. They have no long-term planning. They put their foot in their mouth week after week. They show zero investment in any player on this roster and create far more problems than they solve, all while driving this program into the ground.
Source: Yahoo Sports













Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account