The potential Heisman winners was cut down from five to four this past weekend with Texas Tech routing Oklahoma State to end Drew Mestemaker's run at the trophy. Now, it's down to CJ Carr,Devon Dampier, Darian Mensah, and Jeremiah Smith. Let's see where those guys land after all three walked away with wins!

Ohio State Buckeyes Primary Logo

1. Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State Buckeyes (-144)
2026 Stats: 80 rec | 1,317 rec yards | 16.5 ypc |15 TDs
Last Game: 11 rec | 117 rec yards | 10.6 ypc | 1 TD
Next Game: At Nebraska — Saturday at 12:00 PM ET

Jeremiah Smith didn’t need garbage time to put up numbers this week. To avoid a three-game losing streak for the first time in his career, Smith turned in 117 yards on 11 receptions and a touchdown. Smith has scored in seven straight games and has four games of 100-plus yards, including the past two. Smith became the Big Ten's All-Time receiving yards leader at 3,798 yards and counting.

With a road trip to Nebraska next, then a home game versus rival Michigan. Ohio State’s chances of making the Big Ten Championship Game practically ended when UCLA and Indiana won this weekend, so Smith has two more chances to prove why he’s the Heisman.

Peacock offers one of the most comprehensive live sports streaming lineups available today, bringing together the NFL, NBA, MLB, WNBA, Premier League, NCAA football, NCAA basketball, golf, motorsports, and major global sporting events in a single service.

MIAMI.png

2. Darian Mensah, Miami Hurricanes (+340)
2026 Stats: 3,076 pass yards | 29 pass TDs | 76.3 comp% | 2 INTs
Last Game: 382 pass yards | 1 pass TD | 73.2 comp% | 0 INT
Next Game: Vs Virginia Tech — Saturday at TBD

Darian Mensah and Miami didn’t look good in the first quarter against Duke, then they flipped a switch. Mensah ended up with 382 total yards on 30-of-41 passing (73.2%) and one touchdown. Miami lost Mark Fletcher Jr. in the game, and while the run game was still relevant, Mensah took over.

After two first quarter punts, Miami scored on seven-straight possessions to end the game (4 TDs, 3 FGs), and Mensah got revenge on his former team, if you can call it that. He led them to an ACC title last year, then got the bag with Miami. With Virginia Tech and Boston College at home to end the season, Mensah will have a chance to win back-to-back ACC titles and give Miami their first conference championship.

Utah.svg

3. Devon Dampier, Utah Utes (+720)
2026 Stats: 2,257 pass yards | 31 total TDs | 66.5 comp% | 8 INTs
Last Game: 204 pass yards | 4 total TDs | 52 comp% | 1 INT
Next Game: At TCU — Saturday at 9:00 PM ET

Devon Dampier and Creed Whittemore connected on a 70-yard touchdown to go up 40- 39 and beat Arizona. The Utes were in another thriller, and Dampier put up another magical effort. Dampier finished with 204 passing yards, 100 rushing yards, two passing touchdowns, and two rushing touchdowns with one interception on 13-of-25 (52%).

Dampier has run for two touchdowns in back-to-back games and three of the past four, plus he’s thrown two touchdowns in three consecutive games. If Utah beats TCU and West Virginia, which they should be double-digit favorites in both, then Dampier could be invited to the Heisman ceremony.

Notre_Dame.svg

4. CJ Carr, Notre Dame Fighting Irish (+1000)
2026 Stats: 2,385 pass yards | 26 total TDs | 67.9 comp% | 2 INTs
Last Game: 217 pass yards | 2 pass TDs | 71.4 comp% | 1 INT
Next Game: Vs SMU — Saturday at 7:30 PM ET

Notre Dame absolutely rolled Boston College in the first half, 31-0, but to open the second half, CJ Carr threw an interception that led to an Eagles’ touchdown. Other than that blemish, Carr had a decent game, but nothing to move the needle in his direction for the Heisman, if anything, it went backward. Carr finished with 217 yards, two touchdowns, and one interception on 20 of 28 (71.4%). Notre Dame has their home finale versus SMU this weekend, then go to Syracuse before their revenge tour begins in the college football playoff. Nothing about Carr's season has screamed Heisman, except for maybe his first half against Miami.

Out of the Top 5

Oklahoma_State.svg

Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State Cowboys
2026 Stats: 3,239 pass yards | 34 total TDs | 66.4 comp% | 10 INTs
Last Game: 277 pass yards | 2 total TDs | 64.3 comp% | 2 INTs
Next Game: At Arizona State — Saturday at 10:15 PM ET

Well, Oklahoma State was routed, and Drew Mestemaker’s Heisman candidacy came to an abrupt end. Texas Tech jumped out to a 21-0 first-quarter lead and even despite cutting it to 21-17, the Red Raiders were too much. Mestemaker threw two interceptions, threw for one touchdown, ran for a score, and had 277 passing yards on 27-of-42 (64.3%). His 42.3 QBR and -8 rushing yards were the lowest of the season, and the three sacks taken tied a season-high.

Oklahoma State drops to 6-4, and the chances of Mestemaker playing in December or January became slim to none. Mestemaker is the favorite to go No. 1 in the 2027 NFL Draft, so we likely see him at Arizona State, then at home versus Kansas to wrap up his collegiate career.

Don’t miss out! Subscribe to Peacock today.

Please bet responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700.

Follow our experts on socials to keep up with all the latest content from the staff:

  • Jay Croucher (@croucherJD)
  • Drew Dinsick (@whale_capper)
  • Vaughn Dalzell (@VmoneySports)
  • Trysta Krick (@Trysta_Krick)

Source: Yahoo Sports