College Football Power Rankings Week 12: Georgia, Utah, UCLA Lead Max Chadwick's Top 12
College Football Power Rankings Week 12: Georgia, Utah, UCLA Lead Max Chadwick's Top 12

Week 11 made the top of college football easier to separate from the rest of the country.

Georgia and Utah remain the two teams Max Chadwick is most comfortable putting at the top. UCLA is still undefeated, Notre Dame has one of the best wins in the country, and Miami rebounded after its first loss.

The bigger disagreement is Alabama.

The selection committee ranked the Crimson Tide No. 3 before Week 11, but Chadwick doesn’t believe their résumé belongs that high even after another convincing win.

Here is Chadwick’s personal top 12 entering Week 12.

Note: The attached recording verbalizes Chadwick’s ranking through No. 12. It does not state the order from Nos. 13-25, so those teams are not reconstructed here from the unseen on-screen graphic.

1. Georgia Bulldogs

Georgia stays No. 1.

The Bulldogs improved to 9-1 by beating Missouri 48-21, continuing a stretch in which their only real blemish is the loss to Auburn.

Chadwick acknowledged that Utah has a reasonable argument for the top spot because the Utes remain undefeated.

He still prefers Georgia because of how dominant the Bulldogs have looked against quality competition.

Georgia’s win over Alabama remains one of the strongest results on any résumé. Since the Auburn loss, the Bulldogs have also handled Florida, Ole Miss, and Missouri without creating much late-game doubt.

PFN’s Playoff Meter gives Georgia a 28.2% chance to win the national championship, comfortably the best probability in the country.

2. Utah Utes

Utah is the obvious alternative at No. 1.

The Utes are 10-0 after surviving Arizona 40-39, with Devin Dampier accounting for four touchdowns and throwing the game-winning 70-yard score to Creed Whittemore late in the fourth quarter.

The résumé includes BYU and Arizona, and Utah is the only undefeated Big 12 team left.

PREDICT THE CFB SEASON:PFN’s Free CFB Playoff Predictor

Chadwick still gives Georgia the edge because of its week-to-week dominance, but Utah has done the one thing Georgia hasn’t: avoid losing.

The Utes travel to TCU in Week 12 with a 99.7% chance to make the playoff.

3. UCLA Bruins

This is where Chadwick makes his first major departure from the committee.

UCLA was No. 4 in the Nov. 10 CFP rankings, one spot behind Alabama. Chadwick would move the Bruins ahead of the Crimson Tide.

UCLA is 10-0 after beating Illinois 22-14 and has consistently leaned on one of the best defenses in college football.

Chadwick and Miller highlighted defensive coordinator Colin Hitschler’s work and a unit led by players such as linebacker Tamiya Osemigo.

The schedule hasn’t been as strong as Alabama’s, but an undefeated Big Ten team this late in November has done enough for Chadwick to put it third.

UCLA gets its next test at Michigan.

4. Notre Dame Fighting Irish

Notre Dame has continued moving upward since beating Miami.

The Fighting Irish are 9-1 after a 41-7 win over Boston College, and Chadwick believes the head-to-head victory over the Hurricanes gives Notre Dame one of the strongest arguments among the one-loss teams.

Its only defeat came against BYU.

That combination is enough for Chadwick to move Notre Dame ahead of Alabama as well.

PFN’s Playoff Meter gives the Irish a 99.6% chance to make the field and a 16.8% chance to win the national championship, second only to Georgia.

5. Miami Hurricanes

Miami drops behind Notre Dame because of the head-to-head result but remains in Chadwick’s top five.

The Hurricanes beat Duke 36-25 to move to 9-1 and remain undefeated in ACC play.

Darian Mensah continues to give Miami one of the nation’s most efficient passing attacks even without injured receiver Malachi Toney.

The loss at Notre Dame is significant, but it isn’t enough to erase everything Miami did before it.

With Virginia Tech and Boston College remaining, the Hurricanes are in excellent position to reach the ACC Championship Game at 11-1.

6. Texas Longhorns

Texas remains one of the hardest teams in the country to evaluate.

The Longhorns have two losses to teams that were unranked at the time, Oklahoma and Florida.

They also keep beating good teams.

Texas escaped LSU 22-21 and has accumulated one of the strongest collections of high-end victories in the country.

DIVE IN:PFN’s Free CFB HQ — Team and Player Stats, Info, and More

Chadwick puts more weight on those wins than on the quality of the losses, which is why he places Texas ahead of Alabama.

The offense hasn’t always looked like that of a national championship favorite. The résumé still belongs in the top six.

7. Indiana Hoosiers

Indiana’s 27-13 win over USC put another major obstacle behind the Hoosiers.

They are 9-1 and now control a straightforward path to the Big Ten Championship Game.

Chadwick still has Indiana below the one-loss teams with stronger signature wins, but the Hoosiers have continued doing enough to stay firmly in the top 10.

They visit Washington in Week 12 before closing with Purdue.

With an 88.4% playoff probability, Indiana’s remaining job is simply to avoid a late collapse.

8. Tennessee Volunteers

Tennessee moves ahead of Alabama in Chadwick’s order for one obvious reason: The Volunteers beat Alabama.

Both teams are 8-2.

Tennessee’s overall résumé may not have the same depth, but Chadwick values the head-to-head result enough to break the tie in the Volunteers’ favor.

The Week 11 performance helped. Tennessee went to Texas A&M and won 22-7.

The Volunteers now face LSU in what should be their most important remaining regular-season game.

9. Alabama Crimson Tide

Chadwick’s biggest disagreement with the selection committee is Alabama.

The committee had the Crimson Tide at No. 3 before Week 11. Chadwick would have them ninth.

“I think Alabama is wildly overranked right now by the committee,” Chadwick said.

That doesn’t mean he thinks Alabama is bad.

The Crimson Tide have won three straight, including convincing results against LSU, Texas A&M, and Vanderbilt. Their losses to Georgia and Tennessee are also stronger than the losses carried by several teams around them.

Chadwick’s issue is that teams such as Notre Dame, Miami, Texas, and Tennessee have arguments he finds more compelling.

Alabama is still a playoff team. He just doesn’t view the Crimson Tide as a top-three team.

10. Texas Tech Red Raiders

Texas Tech moves into Chadwick’s top 10 after beating Oklahoma State 52-27.

The biggest difference is at quarterback.

Thomas Castellanos has added another dimension to Mack Leftwich’s offense, and Texas Tech has scored at least 34 points in every game since he took over.

The Red Raiders are now 9-1 and have increased their playoff probability to 58.4%.

They also have a defense capable of holding up against stronger opponents, particularly with Trey White healthy again.

Chadwick initially considered Wake Forest for the No. 10 spot but gave Texas Tech the edge because he prefers the Red Raiders’ résumé.

11. Wake Forest Demon Deacons

No team made a louder Week 11 statement than Wake Forest.

The Demon Deacons beat SMU 49-7 on the road and are now 9-1.

Since losing to Miami, Wake Forest has beaten Louisville, Stanford, NC State, Cal, Virginia, Merrimack, and SMU. Other than the three-point win over Louisville, each victory came by at least 24 points.

Chadwick believes Wake Forest is playing like one of the best teams in the country even if the résumé lacks the single marquee win Texas Tech owns.

That can change in the ACC Championship Game.

Wake Forest now has an 82.5% chance to make the playoff and a 98.4% chance to reach the conference title game.

12. BYU Cougars

BYU rounds out Chadwick’s top 12.

The Cougars are 8-2 after beating Baylor 28-7 and remain in an awkward position because they’re more likely to make the playoff than the Big 12 Championship Game.

Their strongest argument is the win over Notre Dame.

That result has become more valuable every week as the Irish continue climbing.

BYU needs to finish against Kansas and Cincinnati without another loss. If the Cougars reach 10-2, Chadwick believes they will have a serious at-large case even if they stay home during championship weekend.

Alabama Is the Biggest Difference Between Chadwick and the Committee

The committee’s Nov. 10 top five was Georgia, Utah, Alabama, UCLA, and Notre Dame.

Chadwick’s order after Week 11 is Georgia, Utah, UCLA, Notre Dame, and Miami.

That isn’t a small disagreement.

He still expects Alabama to make the playoff. PFN gives the Crimson Tide a 99.8% chance.

The dispute is over whether Alabama has earned one of the best seeds in the field.

Chadwick prefers UCLA’s undefeated record, Notre Dame’s win over Miami, Miami’s body of work, Texas’ collection of ranked victories, Indiana’s one-loss record, and Tennessee’s head-to-head win before getting to the Crimson Tide.

The committee will give its next answer Tuesday night.

This article originally appeared on Pro Football Network.

Source: Yahoo Sports