
The College Football Playoff selection committee’s latest rankings have drawn plenty of criticism for how they treat the SEC, with two-loss Alabama sitting at No. 3 and four four-loss SEC teams filling out the bottom of the top 25. Now, there’s data showing just how far the committee has strayed from the voters.
According to a new analysis, the committee has ranked SEC teams a combined 41 spots higher than the AP poll through the first three rankings, the biggest edge any conference has had since the rankings began in 2014. Meanwhile, the Big Ten and ACC have never fared worse.
‘Take the crayons away’
The committee’s third rankings of the season, released on Tuesday night, had Alabama at No. 3, ahead of undefeated UCLA and an 8-2 Texas team that beat both Ohio State and Tennessee. Alabama, which is also 8-2, lost 26-10 to Tennessee in October, yet the committee has the Crimson Tide six spots ahead of the Volunteers.
Fox Sports analyst Joel Klatt didn’t hold back on Wednesday, tearing into the committee for its treatment of the SEC.
“Take the crayons away from the committee,” Klatt said.
Klatt also pointed out the circular logic the committee appears to be using to justify the SEC’s placement.
“Yeah, but why were 9 teams ranked? Well, because the SEC is really good. Why is the SEC— Well, because 9 teams are ranked,” Klatt said.
‘The CFP’s favorite son’
On Thursday, Brandon Marcello of CBS Sports put some numbers behind the frustration. Marcello added up how far the committee has placed each conference’s teams above or below the AP poll across the first three rankings, and the SEC came out 41 spots ahead.
“At the very least, the SEC has become the CFP’s favorite son,” Marcello wrote. “The committee is diverging from the voters in the SEC’s favor more than ever. The previous high was 34 spots in 2018.”
It’s a dramatic turnaround from the last two seasons, when the committee rated SEC teams lower overall than the AP poll did through the first three rankings. Last season, the SEC was at minus-10.
According to Marcello, Alabama accounts for 12 of those spots on its own. Even measured against the coaches’ poll, the SEC is still 32 spots ahead.
That boost has come at the expense of everyone else. The Big Ten is at minus-5, its lowest mark ever, while the ACC is down 11 spots and the committee hasn’t ranked a single ACC team above its AP spot all season. Notre Dame is down 12 spots, also its lowest mark ever.
“So, in a year where the SEC is receiving more favor than ever from the CFP, its chief rival, the Big Ten, has never fared worse against the AP in the committee’s rankings. It’s those same teams fighting the SEC’s two- and three-loss programs for at-large bids,” Marcello wrote.
The bottom of the rankings is where it really stands out. Four-loss South Carolina, Oklahoma, Florida, and Ole Miss sit between No. 21 and No. 25, which Marcello noted is the most 6-4 teams ever ranked in the CFP rankings at this point in a season. The previous record was two.
South Carolina only fell from No. 17 to No. 21 after a 34-6 loss at Arkansas, a one-win SEC team, that knocked the Gamecocks out of the AP Top 25 entirely. South Carolina head coach Shane Beamer was grateful.
“I appreciate the committee, you know, feeling that way about us. I appreciate the committee respecting what it means to be in this conference,” Beamer said on the SEC’s weekly coaches teleconference, via CBS Sports.
Meanwhile, 9-1 Liberty and 8-2 Memphis are both ranked by the AP but left out of the committee’s top 25 entirely.
‘An SEC loss has never meant less’
The SEC lobbied hard for the committee to weigh a “Strength of Conference Enhancement” after the league moved to a nine-game conference schedule. But Marcello pointed out that the tool was supposed to sort teams within a conference, not to give one conference a boost over the others.
“The tool built to compare teams within the same league has arrived, and in the same season, SEC teams are rising over everyone else outside the league,” Marcello wrote.
Even within the SEC, the committee hasn’t explained the gap between Alabama and Tennessee. CFP executive director Rich Clark said that there are too many metrics to share publicly, while committee chairman Hunter Yurachek pointed to the eye test.
“Quite honestly, when we watch [Alabama] on film, when we watch their games, we really feel like they’re one of the best three or four teams in the country,” Yurachek said.
Marcello did acknowledge that the SEC has some on-field results to back it up. The league is 10-2 against nonconference opponents from the power leagues and Notre Dame, while the Big Ten is 4-10. But he argued that doesn’t justify “a 6-4 team over a 9-1 team, or for a 16-point loser ranked six spots above the winner.”
“On Saturdays, it means more. On Tuesday nights, an SEC loss has never meant less,” Marcello concluded.
The post ‘An SEC loss has never meant less’: Data confirms CFP committee favors SEC more than ever appeared first on The Comeback: Today’s Top Sports Stories & Reactions.
Source: Yahoo Sports










Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account