
Indiana football’s slide from No. 4 in the initial set of College Football Playoff rankings all the way down to No. 9 in last week’s top-25 came despite the Hoosiers being on a bye week.
The reason for the collapse could’ve been seen coming from a mile away: the Hoosiers’ record took a hit with every Big Ten opponent it faced suffering a loss while it was on a bye. Indiana’s one loss looked worse and all of its wins, most of which came by slim margins, looked more questionable in light of more recent results.
This, combined with Indiana’s lack of a game to help cement its status, caused the fall. Now Indiana has that solid win, beating a ranked USC team at home 27-13 this past Saturday. There may not be room to move up, with all eight teams ahead of the Hoosiers winning this past weekend… but what about a fall?
Could some team’s resume have suffered a similar fate? Say, Alabama? Indiana’s Rose Bowl opponent from last season and one of the teams that leapfrogged the Hoosiers last week? It’s not that farfetched, especially if the committee applies its already-established criteria.
I’ll preface with a few notes here. For one, this is not advocating for Indiana to move ahead of Alabama. If that was the argument, it’d be a different discussion entirely involving several teams. It’s an observation on how much the committee weighs (or doesn’t weigh) its own established precedent this season. Alabama is a very good football team that’s positioned itself well this season with as quality of a loss as it gets against Georgia.
Let’s take a gander at Alabama’s power conference schedule, with the opposing team’s playoff ranking (if applicable) record and most recent result:
No. 3 Alabama
- 45-17 W at No. 11 Kentucky (7-3, 21-14 L vs Florida) – *second consecutive loss
- 50-36 W vs Florida State (5-5, 16-10 W at Pitt)
- 49-18 W vs No. 17 South Carolina (6-4, 34-6 L at Arkansas)
- 56-23 W vs Mississippi State (4-6, 41-9 L vs Auburn) *sixth consecutive loss
- 20-17 L vs No. 1 Georgia (9-1, 48-21 W vs No. 22 Missouri)
- 26-10 L vs No. 14 Tennessee (8-2, 22-7 W at Texas A&M)
- 31-20 W vs Texas A&M (4-6, 22-7 L vs No, 14 Tennessee) *third consecutive loss
- 31-13 W vs No. 14 LSU (6-4, 22-21 L vs No. 6 Texas)
- 21-6 W at Vanderbilt (4-6)
Of Alabama’s nine power conference opponents this season, just three won this past Saturday. They are Alabama’s two losses, Georgia and Tennessee, and Florida State. That means that, of Alabama’s seven wins against power conference opponents this season, only Florida State won.
All of Alabama’s SEC wins, just like all of Indiana’s Big Ten wins two weeks ago, lost this past weekend. Some extending losing streaks and others getting blown out by a team with a losing record.]
What separates the Crimson Tide from the Hoosiers is the fact that their two losses kept winning, unlike Indiana’s lone loss to Ohio State. Georgia sits rather comfortably atop the sport right now and Alabama should get credit for pushing the Bulldogs further than anyone. Tennessee is working on cementing its own playoff bonafides.
With all of this in mind, should the playoff committee follow its own established prior moves and dock the Tide for its schedules underperformance? Probably.
Alabama shouldn’t drop five spots like Indiana did, but is there a reason for them to be ahead of 9-0 UCLA, especially with the Bruins’ road win at Oregon looking better and better? Probably not. Maybe Notre Dame, which owns the top-10 win that’s escaped the Tide, would get a look as well fresh off of a blowout win.
If the Tide do fall, it’s hard to see it going beyond those 1-2 spots. But who knows, maybe someone on the committee had some great barbecue before the vote and got hungry eyes thinking of Texas.
Join the conversation!
Sign up for a user account and get:
- Improved notifications system!
- Fewer ads
- Create community posts
- Comment on articles, community posts
- Rec comments, community posts
Download the SB Nation app on iOS or Android.
Source: Yahoo Sports









Sign in to join the conversation.
Comments, replies, Roars, reports, and followed-thread notifications use your verified Rally & Roar account.
Sign in or create an account